I love baking with whole wheat flour. Not just because I believe it’s healthier to use the whole grain, but I really do prefer the taste. Whole wheat products have a nuttier, heftier feel to them. You won’t get “wedding cake” smoothness out of a whole wheat recipe, but then, you won’t have that cloying, gummy mouthfeel, either.
All-purpose flour only uses the endosperm. For this reason, all-purpose flour is usually lighter in color and finer in texture. While it does make a great wedding cake, all-purpose flour is also much lower in B-vitamins (which is why they have to “enrich” the flour artificially), lower in fiber (from the bran) and lower in protein. I just don’t think it’s worth the trade, myself.
(All-purpose flour does have a longer shelf-life, which makes it much more profitable! Hmmm . . . )
You may have a recipe that calls for all-purpose flour that would make a good candidate for whole wheat. I would recommend trying it for any of these:
- Drop Cookies, especially chocolate chip, oatmeal or molasses
- Breads and Rolls (except flaky pastry-type rolls or croissants)
- Batter breads (banana bread, zucchini bread, date nut bread)
- Coffee Cake and Scones
- “Heftier” cakes calling for nuts, raisins, dates (carrot cake is a great choice)
- Pancakes (especially good here!)
There several things to remember when working on substituting whole wheat for all-purpose flour:
Whole Wheat Flour is Heavier – and because of this, you need to work on incorporating plenty of air into your batter. You will also need to bake it just a bit longer, as heat takes longer to penetrate a dense batter.
Whole Wheat Flour contains bran, which is not very soluble in water. Because of this, whole wheat flour will benefit from a little extra liquid and some extra time to sit and absorb as much liquid as possible.
Whole Wheat Flour does impart some taste of it’s own to the recipe. Personally, I like that, but in a more delicate recipe it may overpower the flavor you’re going for. For this reason, you may want to use whole wheat only in recipes that contain some “bigger” flavors, like chocolate, bananas, nutmeg/cinnamon spices, and molasses.
Follow these suggestions when swapping out 1:1 all-purpose for 100% whole wheat flour and you’ll enjoy a better result:
For every cup of whole wheat flour called for, add an additional 2 tsp of liquid – water, milk, juice, etc.
For dough and batter, let the dough sit for about 25 minutes before baking or kneading (especially kneading). The wait will allow the bran to soften, which will prevent your kneading action from cutting the gluten fibers which make the bread lighter.
Give it a try! I think you’ll be pleased with the results.